I watched the All Stars Show hoping that the judges had come to their senses and would redeem themselves by selecting Hilari as the well deserved winner this time. I thought it was a no brainer. It was so obvious whose designs had been consistently good. No such luck!! Hilari and her designs were bright, refreshing, and an absolute pleasure to watch. I would have absolutely watched her show. Both Danielle and Leslie are boring and I have no desire or intention of watching any shows they are on. HGTV, how could you have missed this opportunity for a bright new personality TWICE?? I have no confidence in these judges and will not watch this show in the future unless changes are made.

Agreed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Couldn't agree more&apaprently everyone here also thinks the same way!! What a waste of my time to see someone half as talented&lovable win!! I loooooved hilari's room..it far outshined the rest!!The judges are crazy!!! If its not their boring taste its no good!! hgtv really needs to learn to be more diverse and have different deisners w/different taste..why have the same designer over&over..its soo boring!! Hilari was robbed once&now again...what a joke this show has become!! Geneive's snotty ways need to go!! Nobody on here thinks leslie should have won...take a hint hgtv you really screwed it up!!

Not only did Hilary get the shaft on the All Star show, but also on the last Design Star. Hilary’s yurt was beautiful, and so was her container.

Agreeeee toooo. Only David should stay. Genivive really needs to go.

LOL. I agree. Really, would you actually let Genevieve decorate your house? LOL. No way, we’ve seen her work. There’s a reason why she is a guest host or a judge or marketing bathroom rugs!

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Swedishpie,