Tonight really was an eye opener. Kris was so nice, Miera wasn't! I think maybe Kris had just been edited to make him annoying.
I just wonder if Rachel was really missing her daughter so much that she lost sight of what she was doing. It was edited to look that way, plus we really don't know how long they had to come up with their camera challenges.
I was truly irritated with Miera tonight. Although I was initially happy to see someone older than 40 in the running I wanted to reach out and slap her. It was good that she went home.
A few years ago wasn't there a gal on who became so homesick for her family she more or less just said "send me home"? I thought that's what they were going to do with Rachel tonight.
I was relieved that Danielle squeaked by.
Hilari did a good job tonight - which did surprise me - after that teensy little t.v. from the first show and the less than wonderful white room, I thought she'd be gone.
Kris was much less irritating tonight but he still is weird (he's from Austin where our motto is "Keep Austin Weird").
Yeah, Miera really did kind of prove that old line, "The one constant in all your crappy relationships is you", didn't she? Am I mis-remembering or didn't she have personality issues every time she's had to work with another designer?
So glad Danielle survived. I think she's good and hate when someone gets dinged for thinking more about the clients and end result than worrying about their individual "mark".
Hilari and Mikel really did deserve the win tonight, though. That was a beautiful room.
------------------------------------------------ I've been around...well, all right, I might not have been around, but I've been....nearby. -from "The Mary Tyler Moore Show"
Have to agree, MsW - thought Miera had issues any time they paired her up. Was a little afraid they'd keep her around for conflict reasons but they can simply edit Kris that way again, next week. Also expected Danielle and Rachel to at least receive 1 pass as a result of their previous efforts.
Great room completed by Hilari and Mikel. Hilari has a nice personality. Liked the way she pitched in last week to help out Danielle, too. (Agree with you about the individual stamp/mark v. overall efforts on behalf of a client, too.) Had a feeling the accessories suffered and that's why she basically leaned them all on the tables, IIRC.
Checked out Emily's recap the other day. Sounds as if she knows Mikel personally. She didn't pick him after the 1st episode as one of 4 potential winners and called his white room just meh. She did mention that he's a set designer, IIRC. If nothing else, like Antonio, he s/b able to complete a space within the allotted time. (Can't remember A ever having those issues, at least.)
I too found myself really liking Kris this week. While at the beginning of the season his personality was grating and his design self centered, this week he was warm and welcoming and his design was creative and considerate of the clients' needs/wants.
I thought Mikel and Hillari's room was well done. We have to remember the time constraints they are all under. If their work on the challenges looks less polished than the work in their portfolio's, let's all remember that professional decorating usually involves custom goods, and longer planning stages.
Is it just me, or does the fact that they never do scale floor plans drive the other designers crazy?
Posts: 1494 | Location: Morristown | Registered: Jun 12, 2010
ITA - the time constraints are incredible - I'm amazed by what they pull together each week with (apparently) limited budgets and constrained shopping.
Besides those restrictions, Ep. 4 indicated a 3 day time period but my understanding is the television production requires about 50% of the allotted time.
The lack of space planning makes me crazy, too. Wish they'd at least pull out the blue tape and tape off the room -
Originally posted by bballdays: ITA - the time constraints are incredible - I'm amazed by what they pull together each week with (apparently) limited budgets and constrained shopping.
Besides those restrictions, Ep. 4 indicated a 3 day time period but my understanding is the television production requires about 50% of the allotted time.
The lack of space planning makes me crazy, too. Wish they'd at least pull out the blue tape and tape off the room -
I wondered about the apparent lack of real space planning too. Altho I admit I do a lot of "eyeballing" when working on projects, scale drawings and/or blue tape is better to keep the butterflies at bay. I was glad that Hilari stood her ground and that it worked out so well for her.
Originally posted by doodles64: I was truly irritated with Miera tonight.
I was quite surprised by her this week. She'd seemed so even tempered in past episodes. Maybe she doesn't have the temperament for the DS pace? I know that I wouldn't. But, because of her age, I doubt that she stood a chance of winning anyway.
Posts: 66 | Location: Southern California | Registered: Aug 10, 2011
This week was a game changer for some of the contestants. Some of the front runners fell apart, and others rose to the top. I agree with the judges' decision. I think they were fair. It also shows what a complex job being a TV designer is. You not only have to do your best for the clients; you have to meet deadlines, solve problems on the fly, and engage the viewers at the same time. It's a tall order.
I was happy to see an older designer- but Meira just wasn't good on camera- and she didn't' work and play well with others.
Kris was less annoying this week- and like others said, maybe it is editing- though I thought "I am the king of succulents" was a strange thing to say. He says a lot of strange things.
I loved watching Hilari and Mikel work together.
I'm liking Brittani more and more- but she reminds me a lot of Casey (of Design on a Dime)- so that might work against her.
OK.... and the pair up that I'll never see now, but kind of would like to have seen: Stanley and Meira working together.
*I personally didn't care for the shade of green that Mikel chose- but it worked in the space! I think the over all room really was successful- and I was glad to see Hilari show more confidence- because we are finally seeing her best work.
*Meira and Danielle's room had some nice moments- and if the built in had been finished, I think it would have been a highlight of the space. I think the color selection was blah... but it sounds like maybe the homeowners didn't want it changed? (is that the impression you got?) The furniture selection was not even mentioned- but I think they did a good job with that.
*I didn't mind the Target trip at all. Target is the perfect type of store for finishing off a design. There is no need for everything to be high end. I thought that there were some nice design pieces in both homes that came from Target.
*The chevron wall outside was a great idea- but it looked like it didn't quite come together right. Not sure if it was camera angles or having to work around some weirdness on the wall behind... but the over all effect was good.
*The outdoor spaces were successful- which is good. I hate it when DS sets up outdoor spaces and they flop entirely- so this was nice.
I think these design contestants do a great job when you consider all the factors: They have a limited budget and time constraints for each project. They are away from familiar surroundings, friends, workers, stores and usually working with persons they don't really know yet and with whom they may have personality clashes. They have to cooperate with each other to have a good design. They have to come up with fast workable solutions and lastly they have to meet the criterior of the judges. (which can change without notice). These things do not even include having the energy and stamina to get everything accomplished in such a short time span as the taping of this show covers. With everything considered, I think these contestants do a great job. This is just my opinion.This message has been edited. Last edited by: mriley,
Posts: 1168 | Location: Ohio | Registered: Aug 24, 2010
Does anyone no how to find out what brand paint and color they used on Hilari and Mikel's room this episode. I have looked all over the HGTV website and I don't see anything listed. Thanks!!
I really appreciate how Vern has stepped it up and smiles all the time now. Apparently he's been reading our posts each season. This is supposed to be fun, not a game to the death.
I've been impressed with the designs this season,too. Seems like they've worked to get some good talent on board.
Posts: 4232 | Location: SF | Registered: Feb 27, 2008
Originally posted by Tomatoqueen: *The chevron wall outside was a great idea- but it looked like it didn't quite come together right. Not sure if it was camera angles or having to work around some weirdness on the wall behind... but the over all effect was good.
The points of one of the chevrons didn't match, but overlapped in one place. I thought maybe it was the camera angle, but I saw it quite clearly in photo 8 of the show's before and after photos. I wonder why none of the judges mentioned it?
Posts: 66 | Location: Southern California | Registered: Aug 10, 2011
Originally posted by Soosie: I like the contestants more than the judges.
I second that! One has to be a good designer to be a judge. Some contestants are already better designers than Gen and Vern. Get them off DS and get real designers, like Sarah Richardson, to be the judge!
Posts: 19 | Location: United States | Registered: Dec 26, 2011
Britany Simon is writing a blog on each episode of Design Star for azcentral.com. Her post on episode four is up. Links to the previous episodes are at the end of the post. Click on Home Decor and it is the first post. Sorry, I was unable to embed the url. As for the idea that Sarah Richardson should become a Design Star judge; why would she want to do that? It didn't do anything to enhance Candice Olson's reputation. The thing that bothered me the most about last night's program was the criticism Danielle got for trying to make things right for the customer. Really? I realize that this is entertainment television but the homeowners deserve a decently finished product. Meira deserved to go and Danielle deserved some kudos for trying to make things right. Obviously, I am hopelessly naive.
Posts: 108 | Location: Northern California | Registered: Feb 27, 2010
[QUOTE]Originally posted by wendek: I really appreciate how Vern has stepped it up and smiles all the time now. Apparently he's been reading our posts each season. This is supposed to be fun, not a game to the death.
QUOTE]
I totally agree that Vern and Genevive took notes on the criticism from the past few years . . . unfortunately, too late--they lost a lot of viewers. This message board was a BUSY place a few years ago, but they alienated so many viewers.
Miera seemed to me like she watched people get bullied on Design Star in years gone by and she wasn't about to let that happen to her . . .
Honestly, I felt like the carpenter and her partner wasted precious time trying to discourage her plans for the built in. The carpenter should have had a can-do attitude and just gone ahead and started working--I thought it was pretty nervy . . . I think they should have been able to accomplish it--despite the mess-up with the measurements--how did that happen anyway?
I have to say, I like the tree-stump table; that idea stands out for me as innovative.
Why does this episode still seem bland to me in spite of the nice work that most of the designers accomplished?
We missed the show. Is there anywhere on the site where we can watch it? I've checked on Design Star[s main page, but I don't find the site to be user friendly.
Originally posted by CarolynComparilyn: Miera seemed to me like she watched people get bullied on Design Star in years gone by and she wasn't about to let that happen to her . . .
Honestly, I felt like the carpenter and her partner wasted precious time trying to discourage her plans for the built in. The carpenter should have had a can-do attitude and just gone ahead and started working--I thought it was pretty nervy . . . I think they should have been able to accomplish it--despite the mess-up with the measurements--how did that happen anyway?
I have to say, I like the tree-stump table; that idea stands out for me as innovative.
Why does this episode still seem bland to me in spite of the nice work that most of the designers accomplished?
I watched this pretty carefully and I believe that Miera gave the wrong measurements. She seems to be used to telling people what she wants and having it happen - I'm the same way, to some degree. When I do custom window treatments I always have my seamstress do the measuring, and rely heavily on my contractors, etc. for what needs to be done even when I'm telling them what I want the finished product to look like.
I think any one of these contestants could come up with a credible and pleasing result given adequate time, money and input from a client. It will come down to who has the best camera personality.
Yes, Miera flubbed the measurements. Agree, it's one of those things that wouldn't happen IRL (design asst. would measure twice) but the poor camera challenges combined with her apparent inability to play well with others probably did her in. If not this week, she was going one of these next few weeks, IMHO.
Judib52, IIRC, the full episode videos are listed under the Video dropdown box on the DS page. Don't know if that's where you had issues -
Besides that, they're also repeating DS multiple times this week. It's probably on Sat. night, for sure. If you go to either the HGTV schedule or tvguide.com, you'll find a rerun. Good Luck!
Originally posted by SoCalAngie: The points of one of the chevrons didn't match, but overlapped in one place. I thought maybe it was the camera angle, but I saw it quite clearly in photo 8 of the show's before and after photos. I wonder why none of the judges mentioned it?
The judges DID mention it - and thought it was a plus.
If you look at the before and after photos, there's a slight jog in the wall, so I'd imagine that the overlap was due to the way the pieces had to be attached to the wall.
------------------------------------------------ I've been around...well, all right, I might not have been around, but I've been....nearby. -from "The Mary Tyler Moore Show"
[QUOTE]Originally posted by Piper's Garden: Britany Simon is writing a blog on each episode of Design Star for azcentral.com.
Thanks Piper's Garden for the link to Britany's blog. Something she wrote really surprised me. She said she came in second. Did they announced that on the show? Did I miss that? It seems Mikel would have gotten second.
still don't trust kris.... rachael didn't challenge him the way he has been with others that he worked with. and he took over every space on the patio but the little area next to the garbage cans.... i don't think we've seen the last of bad-kris...
I liked Miera in the beginning....somehow reminded me of Judi Collins-looking, but she grew b*tchy. Reminded me more of that Af-Amer TV reporter from last season. Pushy like her, but Miera had no camera presence. The other one kept saying she had a design show and had been on TV.
Hard to tell sometimes what is assertive vs. B*tchy.
I noticed the funky Chevrons also and wondered if there was a door or something there that made them NOT match up. DH and I both liked the overall look though.
The "Kid's spot" sounded like a great idea but she flubbed terribly. It didn't look very creative or clever at all. Just a couple plastic toys and chairs. I didn't notice the garbage cans until the judges pointed it out. Plus her camera challenge lacked.
Curious to see how they do a Hollywood party in 1 day. I remember a wedding last time but I think they had more time.
Posts: 3220 | Location: Putnam County, NY z5 | Registered: Jun 30, 2004
I just watched episode four - had to record it on my DVR - and I must say I am so glad that Miera (or Meara) is gone. I found her to be a bit of a trouble maker. But I am so glad that Hilary stepped up and won the challenge!
Posts: 1 | Location: Midwest | Registered: Jun 22, 2012
Up until this episode, Hilari has been in her own head too much and doubting her talent. Maybe winning this challenge will give her more confidence. I hope Rachel can pull it together. She is having a "mommy meltdown" guilt trip the plagues so many women.
It was too bad about Miera. I had hopes for her, but her attitude did her in. I too thought she must have watched previous DS seasons and decided that no one was going to mess with her. Personally, I don't think they picked her to win, but to be a token older person on the show. It's regrettable that they can't pick a mature person who has a chance of winning, but why should this season be different from any other?
Originally posted by ntuitive1: It was too bad about Miera. I had hopes for her, but her attitude did her in. I too thought she must have watched previous DS seasons and decided that no one was going to mess with her. Personally, I don't think they picked her to win, but to be a token older person on the show. It's regrettable that they can't pick a mature person who has a chance of winning, but why should this season be different from any other?
Yeah, I figured she was the "token old person" too. However, I must say (and y'all know I'm also "old", being a great grandmother, and am also a design professional) to be fair that this IS an awful lot of pressure to put someone thru. Clients have tried to get me to try out for this show for quite awhile - and, while I have absolutely no qualms about my ability to produce terrific spaces for my clients in RL, I would not be willing to subject myself to this type of situation. I think it was apparent that Meira is a competent design professional and I'm sure has many clients who are pleased with her efforts on their behalf - but at some point you have to admit the younger ones have the edge in a competition like this.
